Case:
The Metagaming Fairy Circle.
Court Acknowledgement:
-
"N/A"
Bailiff Acknowledgement:
-
"N/A"
Ruling:
In Favor of Plaintiff.
Player(s)
Case Summary:
Emma was accused of metagaming during her first ever D&D session because her character was worried that a circle of mushrooms in the woods was a fairy circle. Another player was the one who called this out and Emma was not invited back to another session.
Verdict:
Per Justice Murph "Complaints about Metagaming are like complaints about railroading; and it's basically like 10% of the complaints that are valid." The court agrees that Emma was bullied and should be thankful not to play with these players any longer.
Dissenting: 0
In Abstention: 0
Sentence:
The players and DM are sentenced to take a bad hike with no view at the end, separately from Emma. They are not allowed to metagame by bringing a map, food, water, etc.