Case:
The Herb Witch vs The DM.
Court Acknowledgement:
-
"N/A"
Bailiff Acknowledgement:
-
"N/A"
Ruling:
In Favor of Plaintiff.
Player(s)
Case Summary:
Hannah created a character who creates Healing Potions as their main "thing". They are proficient with both healing and herbalism kits and have spent multiple sessions meticulously gathering herbs for a single healing potion. Once they finally gathered all of the required components, their DM stated that they cannot make any healing potions because they don't have alchemist supplies.
Verdict:
The bench agrees that the DMs choice here doesn't align with the precedent set by the previous sessions and that a compromise should have been reached. The DM had already made the process complicated and difficult so pulling out the rug on Hannah was unfair.
Dissenting: 0
In Abstention: 0
Sentence:
The court will feed poison ivy to the DM.