Case:

The Wet Bag of Holding.

Plaintiff(s):

Defendant(s):

Court Acknowledgement:

-

"N/A"

Bailiff Acknowledgement:

-

"N/A"

Ruling:

In Favor of Defendant.

DM

Case Summary:

While exploring an underwater keep, the Plaintiff's party decided to open their bag of holding "to reequip". The DM stated that opening the bag under water let the salt water in and destroyed nearly everything in the bag. Of particular note was the loss of several high-level spell books.

Verdict:

Justice Tanner agrees with the DM, stating that you can't open your Jansport underwater and not expect to lose your math book. Justices Murph, Axford, and Hurwitz all agree that this is a harsh, but fair move by the DM, with Justice Murph claiming that "water does not care about your feelings". Justice Tanner agrees in spirit, but abstains

Assenting: 3

Dissenting: 0

    In Abstention: 1

    Sentence:

    The Plaintiff must have their computer (laptop/desktop) put into a backpack and dunked into a bathtub. They must also include their favorite collection of Far Side comics. Additionally, they will have their Kindle thrown into the ocean.