Plaintiff(s):

Defendant(s):

Court Acknowledgement:

-

"N/A"

Bailiff Acknowledgement:

-

"N/A"

Ruling:

In Favor of Defendant.

DM

Case Summary:

Caddywack and his party were running through the Tomb of Annihilation where he was knocked unconscious and was being dragged away by a zombie. Another PC began to try to grapple the zombie, but was failing the rolls. Caddywack then proffered their inspiration, but the DM ruled that they could not use their inspiration while unconscious.

Verdict:

Justice Axford believes that the DM is likely "right", but does believe the Plaintiff has offered a strong justification for their case. Justice Murph believes the DM is likely "right", but maybe not very fun. Justice Wilson does dissent in that he believes that this narratively makes sense and there may be a successful argument towards narrative satisfaction.

Dissenting: 1

In Abstention: 0

    Sentence:

    Caddywack is sentenced to go straight into a volcano, where the heat is turned down into a thick, bubble bath (where they will be trapped for eternity).